Key Takeaway

Andersons Pumpkin Pie ice cream pie, 8 inch round ice cream pie with whipped frosting --- The pie is packaged in a 9 inch round clear plastic dome container by Anderson's Frozen Custard was recalled on November 23, 2016. The hazard: The Pumpkin Ice Cream Pies may contain undeclared peanuts.

FDA Food Class I Terminated

Andersons Pumpkin Pie ice cream pie, 8 inch round ice cream pie with whipped frosting --- The pie is packaged in a 9 inch round clear plastic dome container

Recalled: November 23, 2016 ~102 pies units affected F-1229-2017

Description

Andersons Pumpkin Pie ice cream pie, 8 inch round ice cream pie with whipped frosting --- The pie is packaged in a 9 inch round clear plastic dome container

Hazard / Reason

The Pumpkin Ice Cream Pies may contain undeclared peanuts.

Class I: Dangerous or defective product that could cause serious health problems or death.

Class I is the most serious recall classification used by the FDA, indicating a reasonable probability of serious health consequences or death.

Products Affected

Andersons Pumpkin Pie ice cream pie, 8 inch round ice cream pie with whipped frosting --- The pie is packaged in a 9 inch round clear plastic dome container

Food

Company Information

Anderson's Frozen Custard

Williamsville, NY, United States

View all 1 recalls by Anderson's Frozen Custard →

Distribution

New York

Related Recalls

FDA Food Class II

Frozen Cooked Medium Shrimp Peeled & Deveined, Tail Off-White Shrimp; 1 lbs retail plastic bag. UPC: 041220333035

February 9, 2026
FDA Food Class II

Pure Factors Professional Nighttime Sleep Formula and Pure Formulas Sleep Reset, Net Wt., 1 fl oz (30 ml) liquid dietary supplement, Glass bottle with dropper cap. (Individual 1 fl oz bottles (not sol

February 3, 2026
FDA Food Class I

Kirkland Signature Costco item #1181272 Mini Beignets filled with Caramel 22CT. UPC 000011 812722. Product is packaged in a clear clamshell container. ALLERGENS INFORMATION: CONTAINS WHEAT, EGG, MILK,

January 31, 2026
FDA Food Class I

The Tuna Salad product container is mislabeled with a Chicken Salad lid, which states: Molly Kitchen's Chicken Salad, (item#) 789953, NET WT. 5 LB (2.26 kg) per plastic tub. UPC 7 5810830149 8. Distri

January 30, 2026
FDA Food Class II

a.) Preema brand Bright Red Food Colour Powder; Net Weight .88oz/25gm; packaged in small plastic bottle; INGREDIENTS: SODIUM CHLORIDE, COLOUR (TARTRAZINE, CARMOSINE, ALLURA RED) CHECK THE LEGAL LIMIT,

January 29, 2026
FDA Food Class I

Why Not Natural Moringa Capsules 120 capsule bottle marked with lot # A25G051 on the bottom and with an expiration date of 07/2028 stamped on the bottom.

January 28, 2026

Frequently Asked Questions

Is this recall still active?

Check the status badge at the top of this page. "Ongoing" means the recall is still active and you should follow the remedy instructions. "Completed" or "Terminated" means the recall process has concluded, though the safety issue remains relevant for any unrepaired products.

How do I check if my product is affected?

Compare the model number, lot code, serial number, or date range listed in the recall notice with the information on your product's label or packaging. For vehicles, check your VIN at NHTSA.gov/Recalls.

What remedy is available for this recall?

Check the remedy section above or contact the manufacturer directly for current remedy options.

Where can I find the original recall notice?

This recall was issued by FDA Food. Visit the agency's official website for the original notice.

Data sourced from FDA Food Enforcement. Recall information may not reflect the most current status. RecallDex is not affiliated with any US government agency. Contact the manufacturer or relevant agency for the latest information.